An alternative description of extractions in TAG KAHANE
نویسنده
چکیده
The only description of extractions in TAG we know has been developed by Kroch & Joshi (1986), Kroch (1987) and implemented in the developed grammars of English (XT AG 1995) and French (Abeille 1991, Candito 1999). This implementation sol ves the unboundedness of extractions with predicative adjoining, but the pied-piping is solved using a special feature. We think that this solution of pied-piping is not absolutely convenient, because some edge of the derivation tree cannot be interpreted as semantic dependency (Candito & Kahane 1998). Our assumption is based on the fact that a TAG derivation tree can be interpreted as a semantic graph, that is a predicate-argument structure. Moreover this implementation fails to describe some cases of extraction, such as some French dont-relatives. We propose a new description of extraction in TAG which solve most of these problems. Nevertheless, our study must rather be appreciated as an investigation of the limits of the TAG formalism, because we think that TAG is not the most appropriate framework for the implementation of our description of extractions. Tue same analysis is more suitably implemented in GAG/DTG (Candito & Kahane 1998). i. Semantic dependencies
منابع مشابه
An alternative description of extractions in TAG
The aim of the paper is to propose a new description of extraction in plain TAG. Contrary to Kroch 1987’s analysis, our description is based on the fact that the power of a relative clause to adjoin on a noun can be attached to the wh-word rather than to a verb. This analysis solves some problems of the previous analysis, notably by giving the right semantic dependency in case of pied-piping. W...
متن کاملHow to solve some failures of LTAG
The paper presents a lexicaliz.ed depelldency grammar which solves some failures of Lexicaliz.ed TAGs, such as rhe co111bi11atorial explosion of rhe number of elementary trees and the non adequacy for the a11alysis of some constructions.
متن کاملPredicative Adjunction in a Modular Dependency Grammar
This paper shows how to introduce predicative adjunction in a dependency grammar inspired from TAG, MTT and RG. The addition of predicative adjunction allows us to obtain a modular surface syntactic grammar, the derivation structures of which can be interpreted as semantic representations.
متن کاملDelayed Tree Locality and the Status of Derivation Structure
While the derived trees yielded by TAG derivations are uncontroversially taken to correspond to phrase structure, the status of TAG derivation structures as more than a record of TAG operations is less certain. An attractive possibility is to interpret the derivation structure as some representation of semantic meaning, such as a dependency analysis. However, the literature has identified cases...
متن کاملAlmost multiplicative linear functionals and approximate spectrum
We define a new type of spectrum, called δ-approximate spectrum, of an element a in a complex unital Banach algebra A and show that the δ-approximate spectrum σ_δ (a) of a is compact. The relation between the δ-approximate spectrum and the usual spectrum is investigated. Also an analogue of the classical Gleason-Kahane-Zelazko theorem is established: For each ε>0, there is δ>0 such that if ϕ is...
متن کامل